Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Data Models and Cassandra

In a pair of previous posts we considered how we might use CouchDB to store and query a collection of tweets and tweet authors. The goal was to explore the document-oriented data model by constructing queries across multiple types of documents in a loose approximation to a join statement in SQL. Cassandra implements a data model built on ColumnFamilies which differs from both SQL and document-oriented databases such as CouchDB. Since we already have a problem space defined we begin our exploration of Cassandra by attempting to answer the same questions using a new data model.

The examples below are implemented in Python with a little help from a few excellent libraries:


  • Pycassa for interacting with Cassandra.

  • Twitter tools when we have to interact with Twitter via their REST API



We'll begin by looking at how we might query an Cassandra instance populated with data in order to find the answers to the questions in our problem space. We'll close by briefly discussing how to get the data into Cassandra.

We should be all set; bring on the questions!

For each author: what language do they write their tweets in and how many followers do they have?



The organizing structure of the Cassandra data model is the column family defined within a keyspace. The keyspace is exactly what it sounds like: a collection of keys, each identifying a distinct entity in your data model. Each column family represents a logical grouping of data about these keys. This data is represented by one or more columns, which are really not much more than a tuple containing a name, value and timestamp. A column family can contain one or more columns for a key in the keyspace, and as it turns out you have a great deal of flexibility here; columns in a column family don't have to be defined in advance and do not have to be the same for all keys.

We begin by imagining a column family named "authors" in a keyspace defined by the user's Twitter handle or screen name. Assume that for each of these keys the "authors" column family contains a set of columns, one for each property returned by the "user/show" resource found in the Twitter REST API. Let's further assume that included in this data are fields named "lang" and "followers_count" and that these fields correspond to exactly the data we're looking for. We can satisfy our requirement by using a range query to identify all keys that fall within a specified range. In our case we want to include all alphanumeric screen names so we query across the range of printable ASCII characters. The Pycassa API makes this very easy [1]:



The result is exactly what we wanted:

[@varese src]$ python Query1.py
Key: Alanfbrum, language: en, followers: 73
Key: AloisBelaska, language: en, followers: 8
Key: DASHmiami3, language: en, followers: 11
Key: DFW_BigData, language: en, followers: 21


How many tweets did each author write?



Okay, so we've got the idea of a column family; we can use them to define a set of information for keys in our keyspace. Clearly this is a useful organizing principle, but in some cases we need a hierarchy that goes a bit deeper. The set of tweets written by an author illustrates just such a case: tweets are written by a specific author, but each tweet has data of it's own (the actual content of the tweet, a timestamp indicating when it's written, perhaps some geo-location info, etc.). How can we represent this additional level of hierarchy?

We could define a new keyspace consisting of some combination of the author's screen name and the tweet ID but this doesn't seem terribly efficient; identifying all tweets written by an author is now unnecessarily complicated. Fortunately Cassandra provides a super column family which meets our needs exactly. The value of each column in a super column family is itself a collection of regular columns.

Let's apply this structure to the problem at hand. Assume that we also have a super column family named "tweets" within our keyspace. For each key we define one or more super columns, one for each tweet written by the author identified by the key. The value of any given super column is a collection of columns, one for each field contained in the results we get when we search for tweets using Twitter's search API. Once again we utilize a range query to access the relevant keys:



Running this script gives us the following:

[@varese src]$ python Query2.py
Authors: Alanfbrum, tweets written: 1
Authors: AloisBelaska, tweets written: 1
Authors: DASHmiami3, tweets written: 1
Authors: DFW_BigData, tweets written: 1
...
Authors: LaariPimenteel, tweets written: 2
Authors: MeqqSmile, tweets written: 1
Authors: Mesoziinha, tweets written: 2


How many tweet authors are also followers of @spyced?



This problem presented the largest challenge when trying to model this problem space using CouchDB. Somehow we have to relate one type of resource (the set of followers for a Twitter user) to the set of authors defined in our "authors" column family. The Twitter REST API exposes the set of user IDs that follow a given user, so one approach to this problem might be to obtain these IDs and, for each of them, query the "authors" table to see if we have an author with a matching ID. As for the user to search for... well, when we were working with CouchDB we used @damienkatz so it only seems logical that we use Jonathan Ellis (@spyced) in this case.

Newer versions of Cassandra provide support for indexed slices on a column family. The database maintains an index for a named column within a column family, enabling very efficient lookups for rows in which the column matches a simple query. Query terms can test for equality or whether a column value is greater than or less than an input value [2]. Multiple search clauses can be combined within a single query, but in our case we're interested in strict equality only. Our solution to this problem looks something like the following:



The result looks pretty promising:

[@varese src]$ python Query3.py
tlberglund
evidentsoftware
sreeix
...
joealex
cassandra
21


Some spot checking of these results using the Twitter Web interface seems to confirm the results. [3]

Populating the data



So far we've talked about accessing data from a Cassandra instance that has already been populated with the data we need. But how do we get it in there in the first place? The answer to this question is a two-step process; first we create the relevant structures within Cassandra and then we use our Python tools to gather and add the actual data.

My preferred tool for managing my Cassandra instance is the pycassaShell that comes with Pycassa. This tool makes it's easy to create the column families and indexes we've been working with:

SYSTEM_MANAGER.create_keyspace('twitter',replication_factor=1)
SYSTEM_MANAGER.create_column_family('twitter','authors',comparator_type=UTF8_TYPE)
SYSTEM_MANAGER.create_column_family('twitter','tweets',super=True,comparator_type=UTF8_TYPE)
SYSTEM_MANAGER.create_index('twitter','authors','id_str',UTF8_TYPE)


There are plenty of similar tools around; your mileage may vary.

When it comes to the heavy lifting, we combine Pycassa and Twitter tools into a simple script that does everything we need:



[1] For sake of brevity this discussion omits a few details, including the configuration of a partitioner and tokens in order to use range queries effectively and how keys are ordered. Consult the project documentation and wiki for additional details.

[2] Here "greater than" and "less than" are defined in terms of the type provided at index creation time.

[3] You could complain that we're cheating a bit here. When we were working with CouchDB we were tasked with joining two distinct "types" of resources using a map-reduce operation applied to documents within the database; that was the whole point of the exercise. Here we're just querying the DB in response to some external data source. This is true to a point, but in my defense it's worth noting that we could easily create a "followers" column family containing the followers @spyced and then execute the same logic against this column family rather than the Twitter REST API directly. This isn't a very satisfying answer, however; this issue could very well be taken up in a future post.

No comments:

Post a Comment